Table of Contents

Quick answer: No. ICE’s legal authority covers any noncitizen it believes is removable, including people whose only problem is a civil immigration violation such as a visa overstay, a status violation or an old removal order. Public messaging about “criminal aliens” and “the worst of the worst” describes priorities, not legal limits. Detention data bear this out: TRAC reported that as of July 11, 2026, 46,436 of the 65,765 people in ICE detention, or 70.6%, had no criminal conviction.

Richard Herman, immigration attorney

Richard T. Herman, Esq.
Founder of Herman Legal Group, with more than 30 years of immigration-law experience. Richard’s profile · Why trust Richard Herman

What the law lets ICE do

No statute limits U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to arresting people with criminal records. Its main authorities are:

  • 8 U.S.C. 1226: arrest and detention of a noncitizen pending a decision on removal, usually on an administrative warrant (Form I-200);
  • 8 U.S.C. 1357(a)(2): arrest without a warrant when an officer has reason to believe the person is removable and likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained; and
  • 8 U.S.C. 1231: detention and removal of people with final removal orders.

The legal question is removability, not whether DHS calls someone a criminal. A person can be removable for an overstay, a violation of student or work status, unlawful presence, entry without inspection or a prior order, with no criminal case at all.

Civil violations vs. criminal charges

ConductCivil or criminal?Can lead to ICE arrest?
Overstaying a visaCivilYes
Violating F-1, H-1B or other statusCivilYes
Entering without inspection (first time)Can be a federal misdemeanor, but usually handled civillyYes
Reentering after removalCan be a federal felonyYes, and the old order may be reinstated
A conviction that makes a person removableCriminal case, with civil immigration consequencesYes, including some green card holders

Most immigration enforcement runs through civil removal proceedings in immigration court, not criminal prosecution. An immigration judge decides whether the person is deportable and eligible for relief; ICE custody during those proceedings is civil detention.

What “criminal alien” means, and why it confuses people

“Criminal alien” is not one defined term across immigration law. DHS uses it in news releases, and ICE runs a Criminal Alien Program that screens people in jails and prisons. One statute, 8 U.S.C. 1231(i)(3), defines an “undocumented criminal alien” for a federal reimbursement program as someone convicted of a felony or two or more misdemeanors who also meets certain status conditions.

In practice, “criminal” in enforcement statistics can mean a violent conviction, a nonviolent or decades-old conviction, a traffic offense, or only a pending charge. When a statistic says “criminal history,” check whether it counts convictions, charges or both. Some nonviolent offenses can still be “aggravated felonies” with severe immigration consequences; see our crimmigration lawyers.

What detention data show in 2026

Date of dataPeople in ICE detentionNo criminal convictionSource
November 30, 202565,73548,377 (73.6%)TRAC, as cited in the earlier version of this article
July 11, 202665,76546,436 (70.6%)TRAC quick facts

“No criminal conviction” does not mean no pending charge, and it measures the detained population on one day, not everyone arrested during a year. TRAC updates its figures regularly; check the latest numbers and its notes on how ICE classifies criminal history before quoting them.

Who is most at risk

SituationRiskFirst step
Visa overstay, no criminal recordRealScreen for family or employment options; keep proof of lawful entry
Entered without inspection years ago, U.S. citizen childrenMedium to highCheck eligibility for cancellation of removal
Green card holder with an old convictionHigh, especially when travelingHave certified court records reviewed before any trip
Prior removal orderVery highAsk about a motion to reopen immediately
Pending asylum or court caseMedium to highAttend every hearing; keep address and fees current

What families should do

Frequently asked questions

Does ICE only deport criminals?

No. ICE can arrest, detain and seek removal of anyone it believes is removable, including people with no criminal record.

Is being undocumented a crime?

Usually not by itself. Being present without status is a civil violation; some acts, such as illegal reentry after removal, can be prosecuted.

Can ICE arrest legal immigrants?

Yes, if ICE believes they are removable, for example a green card holder with certain convictions or a visa holder who violated status.

Does ICE need a judge’s warrant to arrest someone?

Not for most arrests. ICE generally uses administrative warrants or arrests without a warrant under 8 U.S.C. 1357. Entering a home is different; see our ICE at your door guide.

Can ICE arrest U.S. citizens?

ICE has no authority to remove citizens, but citizens have been wrongly detained. Carry proof of citizenship if you are often questioned.

Herman Legal Group, founded in 1995 by Richard T. Herman, defends people in removal and detention cases anywhere in the United States because immigration law is federal; consultations, documents and filings are handled virtually, and our attorneys travel to court when needed. Our offices are in Cleveland and Columbus (Worthington), Ohio. A consultation costs $245, and a one-hour attorney document review costs $595. See our deportation defense page and can ICE arrest you with a pending application.

Updated October 28, 2026. General information, not legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration rules change often; confirm current requirements with the official sources linked above or with an attorney before you act.

Richard T. Herman, immigration attorney and founder of Herman Legal Group
Founder
Richard T. Herman is a U.S. immigration attorney and founder of Herman Legal Group. He has practiced immigration law for more than 30 years, representing individuals, families and employers in immigration matters throughout the United States.
Why trust Richard T. Herman? Founder of Herman Legal Group, more than 30 years of immigration law practice, co-author of Immigrant, Inc., and a Super Lawyers selection every year from 2004 through 2025.

Recent Resource Articles

Attorney Richard Herman shares his wealth of knowledge through our free blog.

Book Your Consultation

Honest Advice. Multilingual Team. Decades of Experience. Get the Clarity and Support you Deserve.

Contact us

Head Office OH

408 West Saint Clair Avenue, Suite 230 Cleveland, OH 44113

Phone Number

+1-216-696-6170