Immigration Expert Says Move Will Harm America’s Economic Recovery, and That Real Risk to Labor Market Is Continued White House Malpractice in Preventing Spread of COVID-19

On June 22, 2020, after months of speculation, President Trump issued the “Proclamation Suspending Entry of Aliens Who Present a Risk to the U.S, Labor Market Following the Coronavirus Outbreak.” Referencing the millions of Americans who remain out of work due to COVID-19-related economic disruptions,

President Trump suspended the issuance of H-1B, H-2B, L-1 and J-1 Work Visas, effective 12:01 am, EST, on June 24, 2020, until December 31, 2020.

Richard Herman, a nationally-renowned immigration lawyer and co-author of the book, Immigrant, Inc. – Why Immigrant Entrepreneurs Are Driving the New Economy (and how they will save the American Worker), says that this new immigration restriction will harm U.S. workers and the ability to rebuild the economy:

The data shows that immigrant workers complement, rather than compete against, native-born workers, because they tend to have different levels of education, work in different occupations, specialize in different tasks, and live in different places.

Much like the President’s disregard of medical experts who warn against large public gatherings, and their urgent proclamations for using face masks, testing, and tracing to reduce the spread of COVID-19, the President is now disregarding the economic experts. The dominant economic resarch demonstrates that immigrant workers create jobs and help expand the U.S. economy through innovation (particularly in STEM fields), entrepreneurship, consumption, exports, and filling gaps in the labor market.”


This order comes two months after an earlier Proclamation which temporarily suspended some family and most employment based immigrant visas.  The new Proclamation extends the earlier restrictions until the end of the year.

H-1B visas are used for skilled workers and are common in technology-driven industries.  H-2B visas are for seasonal workers such as landscapers. L-1 visas are intra-company transfer visas for executives and other skilled workers. J-1cultural exchange visas are for au pairs, camp counselors and others.


Hundreds of thousands may be affected by the new restriction.  In 2019, the H-1B was awarded to about 133,000 workers starting initial employment with a company. More than 12, 000 people were granted L-1 visas in initial applications, and more than 98,000 were issued H-2B visas.  Approximately 300,000 J-1 visas are issued per year (although many J-1 categories appear exempt from ban.).

While the Proclamation appears to exclude any worker who is:

  • In the U.S. on the date of the Proclamation enactment;
  • Has a non-immigrant visa that is valid on the date of Proclamation enactment;
  • J-1 researchers and physicians;
  • Seeking to enter the U.S. to provide temporary labor essential to the U.S. food supply chains; and
  • Whose work would be in the national interest (such as work related to law enforcement, COVID-19 medical care or research, and activity necessary to facilitate immediate economic recovery).


Without offering any corroborating research, the Trump Administration has indicated that the above-restrictions will free up 525,000 jobs for Americans.

In analyzing the Proclamation, Richard Herman, founder of the Herman Legal Group, states the following:

This Proclamation will hinder economic recovery because it will make it much harder for employers to fill critical positions, it will encourage U.S. employers to move abroad, and it will turn away some of the world’s most innovative and entrepreneurial minds.  This stunning display of ignorance and xenophobia by Donald Trump may play well to his political base, but it will do serious damage to the U.S. economy as we attempt to rebuild from the damage done due to his reckless response to COVID-19.”


The real risk to U.S. workers and economy is not immigration—it’s Trump’s gross mismanagement of the pandemic.”


Contact Our Firm for More Information

Immigration Lawyer

Attorney Richard Herman

Founded in 1995, the Herman Legal Group focuses on immigration law, including family immigration, removal defense, employment-based immigration, investor immigration, asylum, immigration waivers. We are headquartered in Cleveland, Ohio, and have additional offices in Columbus, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton, Toledo, Detroit, Buffalo, Pittsburgh, Charlotte, Miami, and Dallas. We serve clients, in over 12 languages, in all 50 states

Richard is one of the pioneers of the movement by Midwest cities to attract and welcome immigrants who can help grow the economy, create jobs and reverse progressive depopulation. He regularly advises cities and counties on innovative ways to leverage existing immigration law to create jobs and attract foreign direct investment.

Voted for inclusion in the 2015-2020 editions of The Best Lawyers in America© and listed in Super Lawyers© for more than fourteen consecutive years, Richard began his immigration law career by moving to Moscow, Russia in 1993, straight out of law school, to eventually open a law office two blocks from the Kremlin to represent post-Soviet entrepreneurs.

As an authority on U.S. immigration law and a provocateur for immigrant-friendly, pro-entrepreneur policies , Richard is often invited to strategize and deliver keynote addresses around the country.  Has spoken often for Michael Bloomberg and Rupert Murdoch’s Partnership for a New American Economy, chambers of commerce, universities and cities. Known for his direct and sometimes controversial style, Richard has appeared in numerous national media outlets.  Richard can be reached at +1-216-696-6170.

At Herman Legal Group, Your Future Matters Most
Call now to request a consultation

24/7 Evening and Weekends for Virtual and In person.